Carding Kids for Protein and Creatine? Why California’s New Rule Gets Health Wrong

Carding kids for protein and creatine: why California's new rule gets health wrong, Dr. Matt Chalmers

Protein and creatine are building blocks, not threats

In this episode, Dr. Matt Chalmers, DC, CCCN, CCSP, reacts to California’s new rule requiring buyers to be 18 or older, with ID, to purchase certain muscle-building and fat-loss supplements, a category he says sweeps in everyday products like protein and creatine. The stated goal is protecting kids. Dr. Chalmers argues the rule does the opposite.

He walks through what protein and creatine actually do: amino acids are the raw materials for repair, healing and the neurotransmitters behind mental health, and creatine supports cellular energy, hydration and protection against damage from head trauma. In his view, restricting the nutrients young athletes use to build muscle and recover sends the wrong message at a time when childhood obesity, type 2 diabetes and mental health struggles are climbing.

1. What the Rule Does

As Dr. Chalmers describes it, California now requires ID showing you’re 18 or older to buy products marketed for building muscle or helping the body use fat for fuel. That reaches far beyond risky products into basic nutrition.

2. Protein Is Made of Amino Acids

Amino acids are what your body uses to build neurotransmitters, repair tissue and heal. Restricting protein for teenagers who train hard works against their recovery and mental health.

3. Creatine Is Natural and Protective

Creatine is already part of your body. It helps produce ATP, supports brain function, pulls water into tissue for hydration, and may help protect the brain from long-term damage after head trauma, which matters for young athletes in contact sports.

4. Muscle Matters More Than Fat

Muscle is metabolically active tissue that supports long-term health, insulin sensitivity and mental health. Building it is one of the best ways to reduce fat. Protein, resistance training and healthy testosterone levels are the foundation for kids and adults alike.

5. Who Gets to Decide

Dr. Chalmers points out that past efforts have tried to make supplements prescription-only, putting access in the hands of a medical system that receives little training in nutrition or biochemistry. He sees this rule as another step in that direction.

6. Chronic Disease Is Tied to Metabolism

Chronic disease accounts for roughly 90% of U.S. healthcare spending, and conditions like type 2 diabetes, PCOS, chronic fatigue and depression are closely tied to metabolic function. In his experience, they respond when that function is restored.

7. Choose Your Sources Carefully

Dr. Chalmers encourages families to be thoughtful about where they get health advice, to understand the chemistry behind recommendations, and to share good information with friends, especially women navigating hormone therapy.

The overarching message: protein and creatine are among the most basic, well-understood nutrients there are. Making them harder for young people to get doesn’t make anyone healthier.

Related: Beyond Ozempic: Why Lifting Weights Beats Yoga Every Time · Creatine (earlier show)

Transcript

Transcript lightly edited for readability (filler words and repeats removed). A few passages that fall outside this site’s content guidelines were removed.

All right, I’m if you heard about this, I’m surprised I obviously you’re not surprised I’m talking about it. So apparently yesterday, Gavin Newsom and the legislature, the government of California decided that they should force ID 18 and over only to buy protein and creatine and anything that builds muscle or is deemed to help the body use fat as a fuel source. I mean, yeah, I mean, there’s been no deaths, attributed to protein, there’s been no deaths to creatine. There’s been, you know, none of that, none of the branched amino acids, like any things that help build muscle or, you know, help use fat as a fuel source. There’s no deaths associated to them, none.

And so when they’re like, this is for the safety of the children, no. And let’s walk through some of this. Protein is made of amino acids are what your body uses to make neurotransmitters, you know, mental health. It’s also what we use to help the body repair and regenerate and heal. No. You’re under 18. You can’t heal in California, creatine phenomenal to prevent damage from head trauma. So like, you know, sports or, you know, boys, girls, doesn’t matter.

It helps the body heal, regenerate and resist long-term damage from head trauma because that’s definitely not a thing that we want our youth protected from, right? We don’t, you know, mental health and head trauma regeneration, brain function, emotional stability. Yeah, we don’t want, yeah, we can’t have that. Like that’s just crazy talk. Are you serious? Yeah, you want to talk about government overreach. Is this is if this doesn’t like shock all of you like this is one of those things you’re like, okay, like we need to we need to shut this down.

The amount of things that they’re just taking away from people rights-wise is absurd. You know, if you’re worried about your kids taking protein, like we’ll have that conversation and you’re wrong. If you’re worried about your kids taking creatine, we can have that conversation. And again, you’re wrong. These are very natural. Creatine is in you. It’s part of what your body is. It’s also very beneficial for production of energy, for ATP, for brain function, for actual cellular metabolic function.

It’s kind of important. So yeah, so when the government does stuff like this is the easiest way they can tell you that their goal is for you not to be healthy. So that’s kind of where we’re at. And it’s really hard now to be like, no, the government’s not trying to make us sick, taking away critical nutrients for people to function, trying to try to, and this is in their own verbiage, Trying to stop people from getting things that help build muscle Building muscles the greatest way to reduce fat Yeah, and you can’t you also can’t use supplements that help your body burn fat use fat as a fuel source So we’re now doing everything we can to increase childhood obesity Increase type 2 diabetes increase emotional instability mental problems mental health problems and damage from concussions This is not like, I’m not the only one who knows this stuff. Like everybody out there knows this.

So everyone who’s making these decisions knows it. And so when you start looking at this, you have to understand that this is a, another solid piece of evidence that your government is trying to make you sick, is trying to damage your health. Because when they start saying, you can’t have the actual chemicals that your body requires to function, that’s there’s no other way of taking that. They’re trying to keep you sick. Yeah. Telling people, well, we don’t, we don’t want kids to start thinking they should build muscle tissue.

What? Yeah. Like that is, it is like, you know, take this from, it’s I’ve been flabbergasted because take it from anybody, like how much, how more important muscle tissue is than fat tissue for the body, for longterm functional health, for mental health, for function period. But now the government has decided that you don’t need muscle tissue. In fact, we’re going to do whatever we can to keep you from building muscle tissue. And we’re going to do whatever we can from keeping you from using fat as a fuel source.

And so, you know, because safety is, yeah, this is, you know, and again, this gets to the point where I get it, like a lot of people don’t understand how big of a deal this is. But it’s gigantic. This is one of those things, like when they started coming through, and they started, this is years ago, where they started trying to say that all supplementation should be taken off the market and be prescription only. And who are they going to give the authority to give this stuff out? The medical community, medical doctors, who get zero education in nutrition or functional biochemistry.

They don’t have no idea about the creation of ATP. They have no idea about nutritional functional needs if they know nothing about it. And then they’re told, not only is it not work, it’s bad for you, which is a complete and utter, physiologically lie, like it’s like, it’s not even an argument I have to make. It’s like, here’s the chemicals your body uses to run, and you’re telling me that they’re not important. Seriously, that’s absurd. So this is kind of where we’re at.

They’re trying as hard as they can to do whatever they can to make people as sick as possible. Because then what’s going to happen? Well, the government will step in and take care of you, just like they took care of you they made it safer for you by restricting protein and creatine. So that’s where that’s at. So I would start making sure that you have the things you need to make sure that your family is fed and healthy and safe because your government is actively, at least the government in California and the FDA, in my opinion, is pushing everything they can.

Propaganda, gaslighting, changing laws so you can’t get a hold of things your body needs for health function. Yeah, that’s what they’re doing. I’m literally telling you exactly what they just did. And so this isn’t a conspiracy theory is that this is where we are. This isn’t where we’re going. This is where we are. So imagine where we’re going. If they’re going to come out and make protein and creatine illegal to save the children to be protective of the children.

Where do you think we’re going next? You think the peptides are gonna stay around? I guarantee you they’re gonna yank the peptide like this type of idea, we yank the peptides as soon as RFK is gone. And not because they actually work and they make you healthy and they do good things for you. I mean, it’s going to be hard, but they’ll just make them illegal. So that’s, you know, that’s I think where we’re going again, nothing that we’ve kind of just come out of the FDA, nothing like this from California has ever made anybody healthier.

Like all the advice is wrong. All of it. Like HRT causes cancer. No synthetic fake estrogens cause cancer. We’ve known that for a long time. Creatine is bad for you? Creatine helps your body make ATP. It increases the amount of energy that your body produces. It helps bring water and hydration into the tissue to help with, you know, osmotic function, which I realize not a lot of people understand how big of a deal that is because your body is actually a gel matrix.

Anyway, it’s important. Protein I hope I don’t have to explain to you how important protein is to the human functional frame, which is mostly protein. Anyway, so this is I get like it’s just one of those other things like you’ve got to take control of your health. Gonna start seeing all kinds of stuff on social media about, you know, how bad this thing is or that thing is, you know, oh, no, D three is toxic now. And like all this jazz. So you guys need to figure out who you’re going to start listening to.

I would recommend it not come from a government source, but you guys need to start figuring out who you’re listening to. And you guys need to start sharing that information with your friends because this is legitimately where things are under fire. And here’s the thing, like We do this all the time for women. If you are a woman or you know a woman that you care about, make sure she’s getting good advice on hormone therapy. Send her here. I’ll tell her she can go do wherever she wants to do, wherever she wants to do it, but at least they’ll understand how it functions.

There are so many doctors out there who literally don’t understand the first thing about hormone therapy and they’re doing, they’re trying to work on women because they, you know, they, some of them want to help and they just don’t know what they’re doing. And some of them just look at it as an easy way to make cash. Regardless, they need to know what they’re doing. And the idea that they’re not starting with testosterone is absurd. And the reason that’s important is because that’s the way their body was designed.

And so there’s so much of this stuff that’s being messed up and wrong. So again, you guys need to start really locking down who it is you’re listening to, who it is you’re getting advice from, where you’re getting your information and share that with your friends because there is an active movement out to make and keep people sick. And if I’m wrong, fantastic. It’d be great for me to be wrong about this. However, the evidence that I’m seeing is not that way.

You know, just do this. Just a quick, easy thing. Do it this way. Google for the last 30 years and just ask AI, ask Grok, you know, has chronic health issues, chronic disease gotten worse or gotten better over the last 30 years? And it’ll show you significantly worse over the last 30 years. Have we spent more money on that or less money on that? Significantly more money on it. How much of our total spend on healthcare in this country is attributed to chronic disease?

Roughly 90% of it. All the chronic diseases can be fixed. We fix them all the time. Type 2 diabetes, chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, PCOS, endometriosis, all of it, mental health, depression, anxiety, all of those things are tied directly to metabolic function. We’ve known this for a very long time. And now we have control of the metabolic system. We should be eradicating these diseases immediately. We do it in the office all the time. I’m teaching people how to do this.

I’m teaching a class on the 19th on how to work on diabetes. Anyway, that’s where it is. This is just one of those things where it’s just like, look, I mean, we just need to kind of sit down and be like, Okay, we’re gonna, we’re gonna start dividing up our teams and kind of realize that, you know, when you start telling us that you’re taking away protein and creatine from children who are trying to exercise for their health and their safety, like we all are gonna be like, okay, like, okay, we’re done. We’re out. So anyway, I’d love to hear you guys’ comments on this.

I’d love to know what you guys think on it, especially since I’m so deep in it and I know the chemistry so much, like it’s abhorrent to me, but I mean, I’d like to know what everybody thinks who doesn’t have the chemistry background. What do you guys think? It was a fantastic day. Thanks for your time.


 

Check out PillarsOfWellness.com for Wellness updates! And ask me any questions you have at questions@chalmerswellness.com.

I answer them all and look forward to hearing from you.

Comment, like, and interact with other people on their wellness journey. Communities can make a difference. DrChalmers.substack.com

Check out my website: https://pillarsofwellness.com/

Social Channels: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drchalmers1/

X: https://x.com/DrChalmers1

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ChalmersWellness

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-chalmers-a422803b/

Dr. Matt Chalmers

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only. Before taking any action based on this information, you should first consult with your physician or health care provider. This information is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health providers with any questions regarding a medical condition, your health, or wellness.