“Research Says”: How to Tell Good Health Research From Bad

Research says: how to tell good health research from bad, Dr. Matt Chalmers

Read past the headline, check the design, and ask if it makes physiological sense

In this episode, Dr. Matt Chalmers, DC, CCCN, CCSP, takes on two words that end a lot of health conversations: “research says.” He explains why a study’s headline and its actual findings can be very different things, why some studies are built in ways that make a good therapy look like it failed, and how he evaluates peptide and hormone research himself.

From a coffee enema study where contaminated water, not coffee, caused the problem, to a women’s testosterone study that dosed so low or so infrequently that it was unlikely to show a benefit, Dr. Chalmers gives you a practical checklist for reading research with a clear head: Does it make sense physiologically? Who was studied? How was it set up? And what does the full paper actually say?

1. Don’t Stop at “Research Says”

Even journal editors have raised the alarm. Richard Horton, editor of The Lancet, wrote in 2015 that perhaps half of the scientific literature may simply be untrue. Research can be shaped by politics and sales, so a citation alone isn’t proof.

2. Read the Study, Not the Headline

One headline claimed coffee enemas cause colitis. The paper itself showed the colitis came from contaminated water. Another “danger” came from people using steaming-hot coffee. Headlines travel; the details are where the truth is.

3. Mechanistic Research Matters

Much of the peptide research is mechanistic: what pathway does this compound turn on? BPC-157, for example, increases VEGF receptor activity, a pathway tied to blood vessel growth, nutrient delivery and tissue repair. If a peptide turns on a healing pathway your body already has, healing is a plausible result.

4. Real-World Results Count

When people use something for pain, stop, find the pain returns, and choose to pay for it again, that pattern tells you something. It isn’t a controlled trial, but it’s information worth listening to alongside the mechanism.

5. How Study Design Can Hide a Benefit

Dr. Chalmers walks through a women’s testosterone and cognition study. Several groups were never raised to levels where most women start to feel a difference. Another group received a large injection only every 28 days, so levels were low by the time testing happened. It’s no surprise the headline said testosterone didn’t help.

6. Testosterone’s Role Is Physiological Fact

Testosterone supports tissue repair, increases mitochondrial density and drives energy (ATP) production, which matters most for high-demand tissues like brain and bone. In his view, low hormone levels are a common, overlooked reason women end up on multiple mental health prescriptions.

7. Be Skeptical in Both Directions

Hype exists on the peptide side too. Claims like “I blew out my ACL and two shots healed it” aren’t how the body works. Ask: Is this physiologically possible? Who was studied? How much was used?

The overarching message: research is a tool, not a verdict. Look into it, understand how it was done, and decide whether it holds up.

Related: The Testosterone Truth: Why Medicine Doesn’t Want You Healthy · Banned for Helping Women: Inside Social Media’s Health Censorship

Transcript

Transcript lightly edited for readability (filler words and repeats removed). Specific dose amounts have been removed.

Still banned from talking on Instagram and those guys really hate women’s health anyway. All right, so let’s run through research. I hear all the time like research says and research says, you know, and yeah, okay. A couple different things. One, let’s start off with this isn’t just me. So Dr. Horton who ran the Lancet, which is one of the largest, most respected, most well-known medical journals that the West uses, said that at least 50% of all research is fake.

They started looking into it and they started looking at, you know, well, this is a weird thing to say. And then they looked up the university that the study was done at. And there’s no such university or they looked up the doctors who did it. And there’s no such people. And that’s, that is one big piece of this. What you have to understand a lot of times about research is that people understand that if you say, well, research says that people go, oh, well, I will trust it and I will believe it.

And you can’t say things without having research to back it up. And so a lot of this stuff has been made up for political function, for sales function. I know I realize I’m shocking everyone to think that someone would lie to sell something, but it happens. So a lot of this stuff is kind of sketchy to start with. So what you have to do is you have to be able to read the research and go, all right, first of all, does this make any sense physiologically?

And second of all, you’ve got to look at not just the headline, but you got to read it. For instance, I was putting together a lecture when I was mentioning coffee enemas. And when I put it together, I had my AI pull different research articles and things like that. And one of the things it pulled was how bad coffee enemas were for you. And I was like, this is absurd. Just like, yeah, there’s no good research on it’s just all bad. And one of the headlines was coffee enemas cause colitis, which is inflammation of the colon.

And I was like, what is what that helps with? Coffee enemas help with colitis. What’s going on? So we look into it and they use contaminated water. It says in the research article that they ended up getting contaminated water. The container water caused the colitis, but the headline was coffee enemas cause colitis. And so if you just look at the headlines, you would think, oh, well, I read the, I looked at the study and the study said coffee enemas cause colitis, even though it wasn’t the coffee enema, it was the contaminated water.

And then they, there’s other ones about how unsafe they are because they burn the colon. I don’t, I don’t know how stupid you have to be, but you know, if you put hot coffee in your colon, it’s going to burn you. So 99% of functional human beings would be like, it’s steaming. I shouldn’t use it when it’s steaming because I don’t want to pour it on myself anywhere. But yet this thing cause all talk to all about how damaging they were and how bad they were for the colon because people were putting steaming hot coffee in themselves.

And yeah, I would always tell you, super hot stuff’s not good for your colon. But that’s just where we’re at. So anyway, when you start looking at some of this research, that’s one of the things you gotta have to peel in. It’s like, okay, I’m actually gonna read the article and see what it actually says. There’s a lot of research, it’s just silly stuff like that. The other thing is like, let’s start talking about peptide research. People are like, well, there’s no good peptide research.

That is a fair statement, but it’s not fully accurate. So there’s different levels of research. So one of the things that we look at that I like to look at a lot is probably the research I read the most is physiological research. So, or mechanistic research. So, it’s not they, you know, oh, we took this many people and we gave them this product and this is the results we got, because in that there’s a lot of ways you can intentionally push that one way or the other.

The amount of dosage you use, and I’ll talk about the source from here in a second, the amount of dosage you use, how you use it, where you put it in, especially if you know how the physiology works, you can really direct a study to show zero function or massive function, just by the way that you present the data and the way you do the study. And there’s a testosterone one that exampleizes, I’ll go into it in a second. So what you gotta have to understand is, how does this thing work? What’s the pathway, the biochemistry behind it, and is this even plausible? So that’s where a lot of the peptide research is right now.

So for instance, you’re like, oh, it raises like BPC157, increases VEGF receptor function. Okay, great. Do we know it does that? Yes, we know for a fact it does that. Great. What do we know about the VEGF receptor function? Okay, that pathway leads to increased blood vessel function, increased nutrient delivery, you have signaling for repair and regeneration. And so yeah, from a, what pathway are we turning on? Oh, we turn on the healing pathway. Oh, cool.

That’s probably gonna increase healing. And that’s the statement. That’s kind of where we’re going with BPC. People are not telling you how quickly the tendon heals or how quickly the tissue heals. Or, you know, this works better than that. What they’re telling you is that, hey, this is, this pathway that this peptide initiates is a healing pathway that your body naturally has. So the chances that it’s going to naturally function are pretty high. And what we see is it does actually functionally do that.

We have lots and lots of people, again, the best research you can get is sales research. Because the people, you know, especially for like things like that are for pain and for healing. Because if like, let’s say with KLOW, If you’re taking KLOW for three weeks and then you’ve run out of vial and so you quit taking it and the pain comes back and so you go buy another vial and it makes the pain go away again, that’s pretty solid research that says this helps the pain. So, you know, if people are willing to spend money on it repeatedly, that’s a pretty good indication. Again, it’s not one of those things that is a dead set ringer, but this is how you have to accumulate this information.

And then you listen to people, what they’re saying, and people are saying, when I took this, I got better. So that’s how the mechanistic function works. So when you start looking at things like, oh, hey, does testosterone do X, Y, and Z? So testosterone for a fact, this is physiological fact, it increases regeneration repair of tissue. It increases mitochondrial density. Increasing mitochondrial density increases the drive for the body to use fat as a fuel source or sugar as a fuel source because it has to produce more ATP.

The more ATP produced, the better everything in the body works, especially things that have high demand ATP, bones, brain, things like that. So when you read a study that says that the testosterone didn’t help women’s cognition, you have to go, how’d you screw this up? And when you read the research, they gave women a couple of different levels of testosterone. Three of them were never going to be high enough to really affect anything ever. They take a woman from like 20 to like 45.

And that is not a big jump when most women start feeling significant improvement around a hundred to a hundred and fifty So you go from 20 to say 40 or 50 you’re still a third of where you need to be and they go see Didn’t help at all. Well, you didn’t give the appropriate functional dose and you knew it That’s the other side because we know where these levels are already And then they gave one where it was like, you know, it was a significant amount and you’re like, well that works It was done every 28 days. So the first week, first 10 days, they were great. After that, so going to the 14 days, like the two week spread, they were not great. And in the last two weeks, they were completely wiped out because the giant hit you gave them got off their natural production.

And so if you’re like, okay, we tested them at the end of the month, of course, they’re going to be lower on testosterone after the giant injection you gave them 28 days before because testosterone is a seven day half life. So walk through how many seven days that is. That’s four, seven days. So let’s say we start at 10, seven days later, we’re at five. Then we’re at two and a half or one and a quarter. So this is how low it got. And all of a sudden they were like, Oh, we tested them and their mental cognition wasn’t that much better.

Yet you drove it down on purpose so that you could come out and be like testosterone doesn’t help. All the testosterone people are lying. That’s why that research was done. And again, it was political and it was, financial. All right. When you start depriving people of the nutrients their body required to function, men or women, what you’re going to see is that their body doesn’t function the way it was designed to. Men, ED, depression, weakness, gain fat, mental clarity goes out the window, your ADD, your press, just nothing works.

Same thing with women. They get moody, they get irrational. And so what happens when a woman comes into a doctor and says, I’m moody and I’m irrational and like I’m depressed, immediately SSRI. There is no other question. This is why so many women are on so many anxiety and mental health drugs, because they have low testosterone. They have low hormone function. Let’s go thyroid or testosterone in this case, oftentimes run by things like birth control, which also, as we now know, alters functional cognition.

And so now, instead of giving them the nutrients that require a function, you give them a bunch of drugs that are going to further inhibit their problems, further exacerbate their problems and inhibit all the normal function. And so you now have somebody who’s on multiple drugs going probably a little crazy and depressed and miserable. So yeah, that’s what you end up with. And isn’t that a lot of the women we see today? Isn’t that funny? Anywho, that’s kind of how that goes.

And so if you wanted to maintain that cycle to get all that money from the pharmaceutical drugs and the visits and the whole thing from the medical industry, you would do whatever you can to bash the things that help people, specifically testosterone. And that’s why research like that is done. So you kind of have to factor in like, okay, what research am I going to read? Because there’s a bunch of research that goes, oh my God, it really helps women and it really helps cognition. It really helps energy and sex drive and orgasm function.

There’s a giant and he goes, this is how it works because it goes through all the physiological function. This one just said we gave this to women and we didn’t see any good results and so you shouldn’t use it. No physiological function, nothing like that. But the headline, we studied all these women all this time because you get to add up all the different groups, right? And so, you know, three of them, you knew not a chance, the other one, you obviously knew they’re going to feel great for like a week and a half, and they’re gonna feel like crap, and you’re going to test them when they feel like crap.

And so you basically built this thing up to show that testosterone didn’t work. And in your research, you didn’t lie about the research, the answers the women gave were 100% that it didn’t help. But the way you set it up was you set it up on purpose to fail, because you knew how the system worked. And you went against that system. So that’s how that plays. So that’s kind of how that goes. Now, having said that, just not to completely throw all the dark, all the shade on pharmaceuticals.

There’s a lot of people doing this with peptides. You go, oh, I blew my ACL out and I took two shots of KLOW and it healed all by itself. Like that’s not how things work. And so some of that stuff is a little bit crazy. So when you read these things, you kind of have to go through it and be like, okay, how much did they use? Is this physiologically functional possible? What group of people did they use? Anyhow, so that’s a little bit on research. So whenever you see research did this or you don’t have research on that or whatever, understand the shaky ground that we’re talking about.

When we talk about research, and whatever someone says they have research, look into it. Maybe it’s right. Maybe it’s real. Maybe it’s not. So kind of keep that in mind just because somebody has research doesn’t mean anything anymore. If you guys have any questions, drop them in the comments. Talk to you guys later. Have a nice day. Thanks for your time.


 

Check out PillarsOfWellness.com for Wellness updates! And ask me any questions you have at questions@chalmerswellness.com.

I answer them all and look forward to hearing from you.

Comment, like, and interact with other people on their wellness journey. Communities can make a difference. DrChalmers.substack.com

Check out my website: https://pillarsofwellness.com/

Social Channels: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drchalmers1/

X: https://x.com/DrChalmers1

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ChalmersWellness

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-chalmers-a422803b/

Dr. Matt Chalmers

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only. Before taking any action based on this information, you should first consult with your physician or health care provider. This information is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health providers with any questions regarding a medical condition, your health, or wellness.